As a punchout user, please email ECT-punchout@RDOequipment.com for assistance.
Resource Center
{{product.shortName}}
{{product.sku}}
{{product.extended_sale_price > 0 ? product.extended_sale_price : 'TBD' | toCurrency({currencyCode : cartDetail.currency.code})}}
Remove
Cart details ({{productsTotalQuantity}})
Subtotal: {{subtotalAmount | toCurrency({currencyCode : cartDetail.currency.code})}}
Checkout Checkout
An error has occurred during checkout. We are sorry for the inconvenience. Please contact RDO Equipment Co. at (701) 401-9744 or RDOAccountHelp@RDOequipment.com.
Your Shopping Cart is empty
Skid Steer or Compact Track Loader Which is Best for Your Texas Landscaping Company?

Skid Steer or Compact Track Loader Which is Best for Your Texas Landscaping Company?

Whether you’re designing and installing gardens, patios and walkways, providing lawn care services like mowing, fertilization, tree planting and aeration or xeriscaping, you rely on your fleet of equipment every day. 

This is why buying a new (or used) compact loader is a big deal. You have deadlines to meet, a budget to manage and people depending on you.  

Although your needs are unique, you can still find the perfect equipment solution for your landscaping business. 

Here at RDO Equipment Co., we’re proud to partner with and support landscaping companies in Texas every day. We’ve identified what kinds of John Deere compact loaders (skid steer and compact track loaders) other landscaping companies tend to purchase, and outlined some factors you should consider to make an informed decision.  

Which John Deere Compact Loaders Do Texas Landscapers Buy?

Over the past decade or so, compact track loader sales slowly caught and began to outpace wheeled skid steer sales among Texas landscapers.  

Today, compact track loaders are far more popular than wheeled skid steers, representing nealry 80 percent of industry sales in 2024. As they’ve progressed, compact track loaders have become increasingly suited to meeting the needs of Texas landscapers.  

Track loaders offer better traction and stability, which are crucial for pushing dirt and performing other heavy-duty tasks in uneven, often muddy, terrain.  

Now that we’ve identified compact track loaders as the more popular option for Texas landscapers, the next question you may be asking is which one you should consider.  

John Deere’s compact track loaders come in these variations: 

  • 317P 
  • 325G
  • 331P
  • 333P
  • 335P

3 John Deere skid steers with loader attachments

 

Over the last 12 months, here are the most popular John Deere compact track loader models among landscapers in Texas: 

  • 325G
  • 317P
  • 331P
  • 333P
  • 335P 

The 325G is consistently the top compact track loader model for landscapers, for several reasons.

The main factor landscapers choose the 325G is its maximum horsepower without the need for a diesel exhaust fluid (DEF) system, making it both powerful and efficient. 

The 325G is a mid-frame model that operates like a large-frame skid steer and is capable of handling high-flow attachments such as mulching heads, augers, mowing decks and Harley rakes. 

That said, while landscapers in your area prefer the 325G, you must determine if it suits your needs. Here are some tips to help you select the best skid steer (or track loader) for your tasks. 

compact track loader vs skid steer quiz

Factors to Consider When Choosing Your John Deere Compact Loader 

You know your business best. As you consider the tasks you need to accomplish across your job sites, you can’t worry about getting them done on time.  

That’s why you need a versatile machine equipped to handle everything from moving dirt to mulching to digging holes.  

In total, John Deere’s new compact construction lineup has five compact track loaders and six skid steer loaders. Consider these three factors when choosing a make and model: 

Factor 1) Terrain and Jobsite Conditions

Landscapers in Texas clearly prefer track loaders over wheeled skid steers. Compact track loaders perform better on soft, muddy or uneven terrain, while wheeled skid steers excel on hard, flat surfaces like concrete or asphalt. 

Your first task is to consider the type of terrain you work in. 

For example, companies focused on grading, trenching or moving heavy materials across soft or uneven terrain will benefit from a compact track loader. The tracks provide better traction and stability, especially on muddy or sandy job sites, which are common in new construction or irrigation installs.  

These machines also excel in wet or hilly environments, making them ideal for year-round use in variable Texas conditions. 

On the other hand, if the bulk of your work involves hardscaping, hauling mulch or prepping patios on firm ground, a wheeled skid steer might be the smarter choice.  

They’re faster, more maneuverable, and less expensive to maintain — perfect for urban jobsites or residential neighborhoods with paved access.  

Task Type / Jobsite Condition 

Recommended Skid Steer Type 

Why It Matters 

Grading, trenching, or heavy lifting 

Compact Track Loader (CTL) 

Tracks offer better traction and stability on soft or uneven terrain. 

Working in muddy, sandy, or wet areas 

Compact Track Loader (CTL) 

Lower ground pressure prevents sinking and turf damage. 

Operating on hills or slopes 

Compact Track Loader (CTL) 

Tracks provide enhanced stability and reduce the risk of tipping. 

Hardscaping on paved or compact surfaces 

Wheeled Skid Steer 

Wheels are faster, more maneuverable, and cause less wear on hard surfaces. 

All-weather, year-round operation 

Compact Track Loader (CTL) 

Performs better in snow, rain, and variable conditions. 

 

Factor 2) How You Will Be Using It

The second factor your company should consider is what kind of tasks you will be using it for. 

For companies focused on heavy-duty applications like moving large pallets of sod, lifting stone for retaining walls or operating high-flow attachments like trenchers, augers, power rakes, mulchers and planers a larger skid steer with higher horsepower (70+ HP) is often the best fit. If you plan to use high flow attachments all day (without overheating or slowing down) an even larger model (90+ HP) may be necessary. 

These machines offer more hydraulic power, greater lift capacity and better stability under load — critical for jobs that demand strength and endurance. 

Here are your options if this is your need: 

Machine Type 

Model 

Horsepower (HP) 

Compact Track Loader 

325G 

74 hp 

Compact Track Loader 

331P 

98 hp 

Compact Track Loader 

333P 

108.5 hp 

Compact Track Loader 

335P 

118 hp 

Skid Steer 

324G 

74 hp 

Skid Steer 

330P 

98 hp 

Skid Steer 

334P 

118 hp 

On the other hand, landscapers who specialize in residential work, light grading or mulch and soil transport may find that a smaller, mid-frame skid steer (50–65 HP) offers the perfect balance of power and maneuverability.  

These models are easier to transport, more fuel-efficient and better suited for tight spaces like backyard gates or urban job sites.  

Here are your options for lighter duty needs: 

Equipment Type 

Model 

Horsepower (HP) 

Compact Track Loader 

317P 

65 hp 

Skid Steer 

316P 

65 hp 

Skid Steer 

318P 

64 hp 

Skid Steer 

320G 

69 hp 

Factor 3) Budget and Features 

Consider your budget and the features you need on your skid steer. Price ranges greatly across John Deere’s compact loader lineup from $50,000-$140,000+.

Since you know the capabilities of your current fleet of equipment, you understand the kinds of tasks your new tool will perform and the type of terrain it will be used in. With this in mind, find the perfect machine for your budget. 

Buying a skid steer will cost less than buying a compact track loader. 

Here’s how the comparative models stack up in general starting price: 

Skid Steer | Compact Track Loader Model 

General Starting Skid Steer Price 

General Starting Compact Track Loader Price 

316P | 317 P 

$45,000 

$62,000 

324G | 325G

$59,000 

$72,000 

330P | 331P 

$64,000 

$79,000 

334P | 335P 

$99,000 

$122,000 

For more specific information on what you can expect to pay, build and price your own machine here.  

Putting it All Together: Choosing Your Compact Loader 

Choosing the right skid steer or compact track loader for your Texas landscaping company means balancing terrain, tasks and budget.  

If your projects involve heavy lifting, trenching, mulching, or running high-flow attachments all day, you’ll want to consider a model with 70+ HP — or even 90+ HP for maximum performance and durability. 

Compact track loaders like the 325G or 333P offer the traction and stability needed for soft or uneven terrain, while wheeled skid steers like the 324G or 330P are ideal for hardscaping and urban jobsites.   

And if your work is more residential or seasonal, a mid-frame model like the 317P or 316P may offer the perfect mix of maneuverability and efficiency. 

Ultimately, the best machine for your business is the one that fits your jobsite conditions, supports the attachments you rely on and aligns with your budget.  

Whether you’re scaling up your fleet or buying your first loader, RDO is here to help you compare models, demo machines and make a confident, informed decision. Find your local RDO store

RDO Equipment Co.

Founded in 1968, RDO Equipment Co. sells and supports intelligently connected agriculture, construction, environmental, irrigation, positioning, and surveying equipment from leading manufacturers, including John Deere, Vermeer, and Topcon. With more than 80 locations across the U.S. and partnerships in Africa, Australia, Mexico and Ukraine, we deliver creative solutions so our customers can grow and build the world.  

Staying Connected
Join our email list to receive information on featured equipment, store promotions and sales, special announcements, and more.