Compact Track Loader vs. Skid Steer: Which is Right For Your Business?

Skid steers and compact track loaders (CTLs) are job site staples, but choosing between them can be a tough call. Each machine has strengths, and the right choice depends on your job site conditions, budget, equipment goals and technology needs. 
 
At RDO Equipment Co., we’re here to help you choose, while offering the machinery, service and support you need to succeed.  

Whether you’re in landscaping, construction, agriculture, demolition, utility or road maintenance, you need a reliable machine that works as hard as you do — year-round, in any condition. 

Here's how compact track loaders and skid steers stack up, so you can choose the best fit for your business. 

Want to jump ahead? Take this quiz to be matched with your best fit.

Advantages of Compact Track Loaders 

Compact track loaders are powerful, capable machines, with hundreds of applications and use cases. Here are the advantages of purchasing a compact track loader for your business, instead of a wheeled skid steer. 

1. All-Terrain Performance

CTLs offer stronger traction and stability on uneven, muddy or slick surfaces.  

If you work in wet climates, dirt, mud or rocky terrain, tracks help you to keep working instead of slipping or getting stuck.  

With better traction, CTLs are also better at heavy-duty pushing on a wide variety of terrains.  

2. Built for All Seasons

CTLs can operate in snow, mud, rain or dry conditions because of their grip and ground pressure. Which is why many landscapers and contractors choose tracks to extend their working season and avoid costly weather-related delays. 

3. Better for Grading and Heavy-Duty Work 

Tracks are ideal for tasks that require accuracy – grading, pushing, trenching, backfilling and digging.  

 They reduce bounce and improve control — helping you maintain a consistent grade and improve job quality — which is essential for tasks like laying foundations, digging trenches, and other activities that require consistent ground contact. 

4. Smarter Technology Compatibility 

Advanced features like John Deere’s SmartGrade™ and 3D grading systems are available on some CTL models, not on skid steer models. 

SmartGrade™ helps contractors by making the grading process easier and more accurate.

This technology saves time and reduces the need for manual work, which can cut labor costs. The system uses 3D capabilities to ensure precision, improving the quality of the finished surface.  

This can lead to fewer reworks and higher customer satisfaction.  

Technology also boosts productivity because operators can achieve the desired grade faster and with less effort. 

5. Higher Resale Value 

CTLs cost more upfront, but they typically hold their value better — especially if well-maintained.  

This comes down to supply and demand. Compact track loaders are becoming more popular. Companies want their machines to run longer throughout the year. At the same time, John Deere continues to innovate with smarter tech so demand continues to grow and resale stays strong.  

Advantages of Skid Steers 

Skid steers are a strong alternative to CTLs, especially if you work on hard surfaces or have a tighter budget. 

1. Lower Cost to Own and Maintain 

Skid steers are less expensive to buy and maintain than CTLs. They are simpler by design with fewer components and less tech. Replacing tires is also significantly less expensive than the tracks on a CTL, which can cost $2,000-$5,000+ per set.  Skid steer wheels, on the other hand, are typically a fourth of this cost.  

Here’s a quick price comparison: 

2. Ideal for Hard Surfaces 

Skid steers are great for concrete, pavement or gravel. Tires last longer on hard surfaces and they are cheaper and easier to replace. 

In urban environments for example, the frequent maneuvering around buildings and on-roadways makes wheeled skid steers particularly advantageous.  

3. Easier to Transport 

Wheeled machines are lighter, with less robust undercarriages, which makes them easier to trailer and move without needing a CDL. Their simpler wheel system reduces overall machine weight.  

4. Easier to Maintain in Cold Weather 

Some John Deere skid steers don’t require diesel exhaust fluid (DEF), making them easier to operate and maintain – especially in cold climates where DEF systems can freeze if not properly handled. 

In equipment with a DEF system, this is another system operators must take care of, along with the fuel, coolant and lubrication systems, which some people like to avoid. 

Comparison Chart: Compact Track Loader vs. Wheeled Skid Steers

Tips for Choosing the Right Machine